Deryk Engelland: Suspended for 3 Games

On Tuesday night against the Blackhawks, Deryk Engelland hit Markus Kruger. Today, Brendan Shanahan suspended Engo for 3 games for the hit seen below:

Engelland was not penalized  in the game for the hit, but did incur a 5 minute fighting major when John  Scott came to defend his teammate.

Engelland was given 3 games for the following reasons:

Engo has never been suspended or fined before, which is why I am a  little shocked that he received 3 games, rather than 1 or 2. However, Engo did have an opportunity to complete this hit cleanly.

The only part of Shanahan’s decision (and overall analysis) that I disagree with is that the injury on the play  is taken into consideration. You need to punish the act, not the result. While it is unfortunate that Kruger is out with a concussion, the point of punishing any illegal hit is that a player COULD be injured. You could hit 10 players in the same manner, identical hits, but each  hit will not end with the same consequences  because each  victim’s body will react different to the hit. They  may fall differently, they may duck or turn or land differently if they fall or hit against the boards in a different manner. Plus, the person applying the hit depending on their size and force (regardless of the motion used) will alter the end result.

This is the part where I think Shanahan is wrong in his assessment, however, that being said, most of us knew as soon as we saw that hit that Engelland would serve time (and he should). I have no arguments about the suspension because Engelland was wrong in his actions and should be more mindful of his on ice decisions. This was certainly one of those times. But I still think that given Engelland’s clean record  prior to, that 3 games is one game too many, especially in the name of consistency (which arguably, there is none).

The other thing that angered me was analysts calling Engo a “dirty player.” Engelland has no prior history of actions like this. He is known for being a bruiser and a fighter, however that is perfectly legal within the sport and is not the same thing as skating around with your elbows  up all game long. Alexander Ovechkin is known for leaping at opponents when completing a check, but yet has never been suspended nor called a dirty player. Completely out of line.

The only thing that really hurts the Pens through this suspension is that Engelland will not be available to play  in the Penguins’s game against the Flyers on December 29th. That will surely be a physical game. Engo will resume play on December 31st in New Jersey.

Here is Brendan Shanahan’s explanation.

 

Advertisements

2 responses to “Deryk Engelland: Suspended for 3 Games

  1. I agree. If you are really going to eliminate those hits, they have to be penalized for what the hit is, not the result of the hit. Should be considering the league lucky every time there isn’t an actual injury.

    • Yeah. I don’t get it. So Engs has no prior history, if he had, would he have been suspended for a lot more time just because Kruger was injured? What if Kruger hadn’t been injured but Engo had other history? Like I don’t understand that randomness of the games people are being suspended for. Set a damn standard.

      If you break a rule/headshot someone, then punish them, and evenly. Not all this, was injured, wasn’t injured, intent to do this, could have done that crap. You hit someone in the head, you’re gone.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s